Recipe for Raw Tomato Sauce

Tomato is a food of love

Did you know that tomatoes are considered aphrodisiac? (That would be why I’m featuring this easy raw tomato sauce recipe.) In fact, some historians believe that the tomato, not the apple, may have been the original fruit of temptation. (Others theorize it is the fig, but we’ll explore the aphrodisiac history of figs another day.) You can learn more about the aphrodisiac potential of tomatoes in my Guide to Aphrodisiac Foods.

In the meantime, I challenge you to experience them at their peak with this raw tomato sauce recipe.

RELATED: Tomato Aphrodisiac Benefits

What is a raw tomato sauce?

What most of us know as tomato sauce is a slow-cooked sauce rich with the flavors of tomato and garlic, blended with herbs and spices. It is cooked low and slow until it bubbles and thickens and the bright, sweetness of the tomato shines. That is a very different sauce than a raw tomato sauce!

TO TRY: Low Stress Tomato Jam

Raw tomato sauce relies on the finest fruits of the season. (Yes, tomato is a fruit.) This kind of sauce relies on the faint sweetness and bright acidity of the tomato. It must only be made when tomatoes are at the peak of ripeness.

Why?

In winter the tomatoes available at the market are a sad shadow of the sensual, crimson summer fruit we can enjoy this time of year. Winter tomatoes are, at best sweet although restrained in flavor with a skin as tough as a rhinoceros pelt.

And at worst, they’re mealy, mushy with an interior the greyish-pink color of a nursing home infirmary. So that’s why in winter I prefer my tomatoes reduced down into a rich, spice-filled sauce, most definitely not a raw tomato sauce. But when tomatoes are at their peak, I just want to showcase them in the raw. I love to let their natural sweetness and tangy juices shine.

Want to save the flavor of your summer tomatoes to savor all winter long? Don’t miss our Tomato Jam recipe. 

A great raw tomato pasta sauce is kissed by the sun

I want to celebrate the stunning flavor of the tomato water; to luxuriate in their perfect, sweet, juicy, fruity goodness. What is tomato water? A phenomenon introduced to me by Chef Ken Oringer, tomato water is the fragrant, blush colored juice that’s released from a cut raw tomato picked at the peak of ripeness.

To strain your fresh tomato sauce

I do not drain any of the water for this recipe, which means, depending on your tomatoes, your raw pasta sauce can be quite thin. You can strain out some of the water if you like a thicker sauce. Simply add the chopped tomatoes to a strainer over a bowl before you add them to the tomato puree. Let them rest for about five minutes before continuing to step three of the instructions. Do not discard the tomato water! It is surprisingly delicious on its own as a virtually calorie free shot of soup or palate cleanser.

Although it is the tomato water at the base of this recipe for a a raw tomato sauce, it’s the quality of the tomatoes combine with the faintest blend of seasoning and herbs that makes this sauce one of my favorite summer recipes. It’s a fresh tomato spaghetti sauce recipe that, when the weather is right, is the exactly what you should bring to the table for a low-stress, date night dinner.

Serve this fresh tomato sauce for pasta with whole wheat spaghetti

You can serve this fresh tomato with whatever pasta you prefer but I like to serve it with spaghetti, a traditional stye of pasta to serve with tomato sauce. Just to add to the nutrition, not to mention the nutrients that promote sexual health, I use whole wheat spaghetti. But you can make it a gluten free pasta dish by using a brown rice or quinoa pasta. The choice is up to you. But unless you’re serving a vegan fresh tomato pasta dish, I recommend going heavy on the Parmesan cheese. What can I say? I love cheese!

TO TRY: The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipe

Whole Wheat Spaghetti with Raw Tomato Sauce

Print Recipe

Cook ModePrevent your screen from going dark

This simple pasta recipe makes a healthy meal from the lusty flavor of fresh, raw, ripe summer tomatoes. 

Course Main Course

Cuisine Italian

Dish Type pasta

Cooking Style Vegetarian

Diet and Health Healthy

Seasonal Labor Day, summer

Ingredient spaghetti, tomato

Prep Time 15 mins

Cook Time 10 mins

Total Time 25 mins

Servings 4 servings

Author Amy Reiley

Ingredients

• 1 ½ lbs ripe garden tomatoes
• 1 clove garlic optional
• ¼ cup fresh basil
• 1 Tbsp fresh garlic chives use regular chives if the garlic variety is unavailable
• 1 tsp fresh tarragon
• 1 Tbsp red wine vinegar
• ½ tsp coarse salt
• pinch black pepper
• ½ tsp granulated sugar optional
• ½ lb whole wheat spaghetti*
• 1 tsp olive oil
• approx. 4 Tbsp freshly grated parmesan for serving

Instructions

• Wash the tomatoes and divide out one third. Take that third and pulse it in a food processor or heavy duty blender, (I use a Vitamix), until it’s frothy soup. If you like your pasta sauce particularly garlicky, you can add the clove of garlic here and pulse until fully pureed.
• Core the other two thirds of the tomatoes and chop into ½ inch pieces.
• Toss the chopped tomatoes into a mixing bowl with the pureed tomatoes, basil, garlic chives, tarragon, red wine vinegar, salt and pepper. If your tomatoes aren’t peak-of-the-season sweet and juicy, you may want to add the sugar. But ripe, in-season tomatoes should be sweet enough on their own.
• Gently toss the mixture to fully incorporate and adjust seasoning to your personal taste. The tomato sauce can be prepared in advance and rest at room temperature until serving time.
• Make the pasta according to the package instructions, cooking to al dente. (You can cook the pasta to full doneness if you prefer, but I find biting into a strand of spaghetti with just a hint of firmness at the center to be a far more sensual experience.)
• Transfer the drained pasta and toss with the olive oil then top with the raw tomato sauce.
• Serve warm or at room temperature with a sprinkle of parmesan. (I recommend a tablespoon per serving but adjust to suit your preferences.) If you like your sauce thick, you may want to strain out some of the tomato "water," as this sauce is quite thin. But you can serve the remaining tomato water as a palate cleansing soup--try it! It's delicious!

Notes

*This recipe works with any type of spaghetti. I use whole wheat for the boost of vitamin E as well as the deep, nutty, woodsy flavor it adds to the dish. But you should feel free to substitute with brown rice pasta, spelt pasta or the white kind.

Note: The pasta is perfect for a picnic but I recommend traveling with the pasta and the sauce in separate containers.Transport the pasta at room temperature and top with the sauce and cheese when serving.

Pin this recipe for a raw homemade tomato sauce: